Private messaging in

The social bookmarking service does not offer private messaging between users, but it does offer several features which may be combined to simulate it.

Using for: tagging, I can send one of my bookmarks to another user. However, this bookmark and tag are visible in my public list. By turning on the new, experimental private bookmarks feature (available from the settings page), I can prevent a bookmark from being shared. Combining these two features allows me to send a private message to another user.

I prefer to fill in the URL field with "about:blank", the title field with the subject, the description field with my message, and the tags field with "for:JoeUserName @privatemessage". The next time JoeUserName logs in, there will be a message in the header area stating that there is a new link for them. Upon viewing (only available to the user), my message will appear.


Of course, it isn't quite that simple. Since uses the URL field to index the bookmarks, creating another message with the URL about:blank and for: the same person will update that link (perhaps silently) on the other user's for: page. However, deleting the original message will leave it be on the for: page.

Possible solutions:

  • Delete the message as soon as you've "sent" it.
  • Use a random string as the URL

Remaining questions

I will investigate these unknowns:

  • What happens if I change the for: designation to someone else's account?
  • What happens if I delete a message and create a new one with the same URL?
  • What happens if I delete a message and create a new one with the same URL and a new for: designation?
  • Can I recall messages by modifying them somehow?
  • I assume this will work for sending out multiple private messages (like a BCC). Does it?

Responses: 1 so far Feed icon

  1. — Do You use an Online Bookmarking Service? | CREN BLoG says:

    [...] 1. Import all of your existing bookmarks instantly 2. Create a a free account so that you can login from any computer to access your bookmarks 3. Share your bookmarks with other people through your “network”, and through a customized URL given when you start your account: 4. Tag your sites with keywords for easy future lookup 5. Give all of your bookmarks descriptions. 6. Browse popular subjects and topics and discover sites that are popular to other users. 7. Bookmark your own site to see how many other people have it saved. 8. There is evidence to show that Google may look at sites like in the future to see what sites are popular and it may become a part of their search results. 9. Intall the button on your browser so you can easily add your bookmarks. 10. Send private messages to other users with these 2 tricks: 1, 2 11. Create an RSS feed of your bookmars to let others know when it has been updated. [...]

Commenting is not yet reimplemented after the Wordpress migration, sorry! For now, you can email me and I can manually add comments.